Prons and Cons of Company Reporting
Accounting and Business Study, Vol. forty five. No . 3 2010 Intercontinental Accounting Coverage Forum, pp. 259-273
The pros and cons of regulating company reporting: a vital review of the arguments Robert Bushman and Wayne Ur. Landsman*
Summary вЂ” In this paper, all of us distil essential insights about the dangerous financial credit reporting from the academic literature. The key objective is to synthesise extant theory to provide a basis intended for evaluating significance of pressures on the dangerous financial accounting following the new financial crisis. We succinctly formulate arguments put forth both to get and against the regulation of business disclosure and standard-setting. We all then analyze current developments suggesting that accounting standard-setting is at likelihood of becoming entangled in a internet of political forces with potentially significant consequences. The crisis has taken into sharpened focus the point that the regulation of corporate revealing is just one particular piece of a greater regulatory setup, and that makes are at enjoy that would subjugate accounting standard-setting to wider regulatory needs. Recent activities by the European Commission in relation to IFRS 9 and proposed legislation in the US Congress to create a systemic risk council serve to illustrate this time. We deduce by discussing in detail the recent reasonable value issue as a case study of the manner in which bank regulatory policy and accounting standard-setting decisions had been jointly identified as a probably socially ideal means to reduce the effects of the financial crisis. Keywords: regulation; corporate reporting; governmental policies
1 . Launch
History attests to the effect of problems and scandals as a great impetus pertaining to regulatory involvement by politicians (Banner, 1997; Reinhart and Rogoff, 2008). After a group of scandals in the UK in the nineties culminating inside the collapse of Barings Traditional bank, there was a dramatic change in the structure of Г±nancial regulation that consolidated legislation responsibilities beneath the auspices with the Financial Services Power. A say of financial scandals epitomised by the Enron ordeal catalysed fast and capturing ciianges to US securities regulations with the passage from the Sarbanes Oxley Act of 2002. Today, in the post occurences of the financial crisis of 2007-2009, financial accounting standard-setting discovers itself attracted into the orbit of complicated political processes focused on restructuring the dangerous the world's financial marketplaces. The problems has ignited woddwide issue on issues of systemic risk plus the role played out by monetary regulation in creating and exacerbating the crisis. Proposals abound for how dangerous financial markets and finance institutions should be changed to mitigate the potential вЂўThe experts are at Kenan-Flagler Business Institution, University of North Carolina. This kind of paper have been prepared pertaining to presentation and discussion at the Information for Better Market segments Conference, paid by the Commence of Chartered Accountants of England and Wales, 14-15 December 2009. We give thanks to Dan Amiram, Mary Barth, Elieia Cowins, Martien Lubberink, Brian Singleton-Green and Dorrie Zeff for helpful comments. Correspondence needs to be addressed to: Professor Robert Bushman, Kenan-Flagler Business Institution, The Unversity of North Carolina, CB #3490, Chapel Slope, NC 27599-3490, USA. E-mail: [email protected] edu.
for this kind of large-scale economical meltdowns inside the fixture. The scope of regulatory problems under argument spans many aspects of the financial system, including the supposed role performed by economic accounting standards in deepening the flight of the turmoil. The crisis has energised politicians, regulators, and economic analysts to scrutinise financial accounting standards because never ahead of, creating significant pressure intended for change (see, e. g. G-20, 2009). Given mounting momentum intended for potentially significant regulatory transform, this is an opportune instant to take a step back and carefiilly consider tips on how to organise the analysis...
References: Admati, A. atid Pfleiderer, P. (2000). 'Forcing organizations to talk: monetary disclosure regulation and externalities '. Overview of Financial Research, 13: 479-515. Adrian, Big t. and Tibia, H. H. (2009). 'Liquidity and power '. Content in press. Journal of Financial Intermediation. Ball, R., Kothari, S. G. and Robin the boy wonder, A. (2000). 'The effect of international institutional factors on properties of accounting revenue '. Diary of Accounting and Economics, 29: 1-51. Ball, L., Robin, A. and Wu, J. S. (2003). 'Incentives versus requirements: properties of accounting salary in four East Asian countries '. Diary of Accounting and Economics, 36: 235-270. Banner, H. (1997). 'What causes new securities control? 300 numerous years of evidence '. Washington University Law Quarterly, 75(2): 849-855. Barth, M., Caprio, G. and Levine, R. (2006). Rethinking Financial institution Supervision and Regulation: Right up until Angels Govern, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University or college Press. Barth, M. Electronic., Landsman, Watts. R. and Lang, Meters. (2008). 'International accounting specifications and accounting quality '. Journal of Accounting Study, 46: 467-498. Bushman, R. and Williams, C. (2009). 'Accounting acumen, loan reduction provisioning, and discipline of banks ' risktaking '. Working conventional paper. University of North Carolina and University of Michigan. Bushman, R., Piotroski, J. and Smith A. (2004). 'What determines business transparency? '. Journal of Accounting Research, 42: 207-252. CEBS (2007). 'Analytical statement on prudential filters to get regulatory capital '. Committee of European Banking Supervisors. 5 August, http://www.c-ebs.org/getdoc/ d0ce6620-b3f7^0a5-8e5b-bc380f22f6ce/ 145Final_Analytical_report_on_prudential_filters. aspx. CEBS (2009). 'Assessment of banks Expoliar 3 disclosures '. Committee of Western european Banking Supervisors 24 Summer. http://www.c-ebs.org/getdoc/6efe3a55-b5c5-4f73-a6afa7b24177e773/CEBS-2009-134-Final-published-% 28Transparency-assess. aspx. Coase, R. (1960). 'The Issue of Interpersonal Cost '. Journal of Law and Economics, 3(): 1вЂ”44. Coffee, J. (1984). 'Market failure and the financial case for a mandatory disclosure system '. Virginia Law Assessment, 70: 717-753. Coffee, T. C. (2007). 'Law plus the market: the effect of observance '. University of Pa Law Assessment, 156: 229-258. Daske, They would., Hail, D., Leuz, C. and Verdi, R. (2008). 'Mandatory IFRS reporting around the world: early evidence on the monetary consequences '. Journal of Accounting Exploration, 46: 1085-1142. Demsetz, They would. (1969). 'Information and performance: another standpoint '. Diary of Legislation and Economics, 12 The spring. Djankov, S i9000., Glaeser, E., La Porta, R., Lopez-de-Silanes, F. and Shleifer, A. (2003). 'The new comparative economies '. Journal of Comparative Economics, 31: 595-619. Dugan, M. (2009). 'Loan loss provisioning and procyclicality '. Feedback by Ruben C. Dugan, Comptroller in the Currency, before the Institute of International Bankers, 2 Mar 2009. Absorb dyes, R. and Sunder, S. (2001). 'Why not permit the FASB and IASB requirements to remain competitive in the US? ' Accounting Perimetre, 15: 257-271. Easterbrook, N. and Fischel, D. (1984). 'Mandatory disclo-
272 sure and the safety of investors '. Virginia Law Assessment, 70: 669-715. FASB (1998). Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No . 133, Accounting intended for Derivative Devices and Hedge Activities. Norwalk, CT: Economical Accounting Requirements Board. FASB (2003). Assertion of Financial Accounting Standards Number 115, Accounting for Certain Investments in Debt and Equity Investments. Norwalk, COMPUTERTOMOGRAFIE: Financial Accounting Standards Panel. FASB (2006). Statemetit of Financial Accounting Standards No . 157, Fair Value Measurements. Norwalk, CT: Economic Accounting Standards Board. FASB (2007). The Fair Worth Option for Financial Assets and Financial Debts - Which includes an Modification of FASB Statement Number 115. Norwalk, CT: Economic Accounting Requirements Board. FASB (2009a). FASB Staff Situation No . FAS 157-4, Identifying Fair Value When the Amount and Standard of Activity intended for the Property or The liability Have Considerably Decreased and Identifying Ventures That Are Not Organised. Norwalk, CT: Financial Accounting Standards Panel. FASB (2009b). FASB Staff Position Number FAS 115-2 and FAS 124вЂ”2, Recognition and Display of Other-ThanTemporary. Norwalk, COMPUTERTOMOGRAFIE: Financial Accounting Standards Board. FASB (2009c). FASB StaffPosition No . FAS 107-1 and APB 28-1 Interim Disclosures about Good Value of Financial Instruments. Norwalk, CT: Monetary Accounting Standards Board. FASB (2009d). Accounting for Economic Instruments: Synopsis of Decisions Reached to Date since October 26, 2009. Economic Accounting Specifications Board. FSF (2009). Record of the Monetary Stability Online community on Handling Procyclicality inside the Financial System. Monetary Stability Discussion board [now renamed because Financial Balance Board]. G-20 (2009). Progress Report around the Actions to market Financial Regulating Reform. Released by the US Chair with the Pittsburgh G-20 Summit, 25 September 2009. G-20 Financial Ministers and Central Traditional bank Governors. Gadinis, S. and Jackson, They would. E. (2007). Markets While Regulators: A Survey. Harvard Law Institution. Grossman, T. (1981). 'The informational part of guarantees and private disclosure about item quality '. Journal of Law and Economics, 24: 461вЂ”483. Huizinga H. and Laeven, D. (2009). 'Accounting discretion of banks within a financial crisis '. Working conventional paper, Intemational Financial Fund. IASB (2003). Intercontinental Accounting Standard 39: Financial Instruments: Reputation and Measurement. London, UK: Intemational Accounting Standards Table. IASB (2005). International Accounting Standard 39: Financial Tools: Recognition and MeasurementThe Good Value Choice, London, UK. Intemational Accounting Standards Plank. IASB (2009). Request for details, June 2009, London, UK. Intemational Accounting Standards Plank. Jackson, They would. E. and Roe, M. J. (2008). 'Private and public enforcement of investments laws: resource based evidence '. Unpublished manuscript. Harvard Law School. Kothari, S. R, Ramanna, K. and Skinner, G. (2009). 'What should GAAP look like? A survey and economic analysis '. Doing work paper. School of Chicago, il, Harvard and MIT.
ACCOUNTING AND BUSINESS RESEARCH Lambert, R., Leuz, C. and Verrecchia, Ur. (2007). 'Accounting information, disclosure and the cost of capital '. Journal of Accounting Analysis, 45: 385-420. Lang, M., Raedy, L. and Wilson, W. (2006). 'Eamings managing and get across listing: happen to be reconciled eamings comparable to ALL OF US eamings? '. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 40: 255-283. La Porta, L., Lopez-de-Silanes, Farrenheit. and Shleifer, A. (2006). 'What functions in securities laws? ' The Journal of Financing, 61: 1-32. Leuz, C. and Wysocki, P. (2008). 'Economic implications of financial revealing and disclosure regulation: An overview and suggestions for future research '. Doing work paper. College or university of Chicago. Lo, A. (2009). 'The feasibility of systemic risk measurement '. Written Accounts of Claire W. Lo prepared to get the US Property of Reps Financial Services Committee, 19 Oct 2009. Electric copy offered by: http://ssm.com/abstract=1497682. Mahoney, P. (1995). 'Mandatory disclosure as a way to agency complications '. The University of Chicago Legislation Review, 62: 1047-1112. Milgrom, P. and Roberts, J. (1986). 'Relying on the info of interested parties '. Rand Journal of Economics, 17: 18-32. Peltzman, H. (1976). 'Toward a more basic theory of regulation '. Journal of Law and Economics, 19: 211-240. Pigou, A. (1938). The Economics of Welfare. London: Macmillan and Company. (originally posted 1920). Plantin, G., Sapra, H. and Shin. They would. S. (2008a). 'Fair worth accounting and financial stableness '. Economic Stability Assessment, 12. Banque de Italy, Paris. Plantin, G., Sapra, H. and Shin, H. S. (2008b). 'Marking-tomarket: remedio or Pandora 's package '. Journal of Accounting Research, 46: 435-460. Posner, R. (1974). 'Theories of economic control '. Bells Journal of Economics and Management Scientific research, 5(2): 335-358. PdcewaterhouseCoopers (2009). 'Changes staying considered to economical instruments accounting '. DataLine: A look at current financial revealing issues. 19 November 2009. Power, Meters. (2010). 'Fair value accounting, financial economics and the transformation of trustworthiness '. Accounting and Organization Research, 40(3) (Special Issue): 197-210. Depending on a address delivered last season, http://www.icaew. com/index. cfhT/route/168423/icaew_ga/en/Faculties/ Economic Reporting/Information_for_better_markets/ P_D Leake_Lecture_Fair_value_the_influence_of_financial_economic
s_on_accounting. Ramanna, T. (2008). 'The implications of unverifiable fairvalue accounting: facts from the political economy of goodwill accounting '. Log of Accounting & Economics, 45: 253-281. Reinhart, C. and Rogoff, K. (2008). 'This time is different: a panoramic look at of 8-10 centuries of financial crises '. NBER Doing work Paper No . 13882. Rochet, J-C. (2005). Prudential Coverage, Monetary and Economic Research (Special Edition) October 2005. SEC (1973). Accounting Series Release Number 150, Assertion of Plan on the Business and Improvement of Accounting Principles and Standards. Investments and Exchange Commission. SEC (2007). Final Rule: Acceptance from International Private Issuers of Financial Claims Prepared according to Intemational Financial Reporting Requirements without
Volume. 40, Number 3. 2010 International Accounting Policy Discussion board
273 ing standards within and across international limitations '.
Journal of Accounting and Community Policy, 2 1: two 1 9 - a couple of 3 4.
Reconciliation to US GAAP. Securities and Exchange Commission. SEC (2008). Roadmap pertaining to the Potential Use of Financial Claims Prepared according to Intemational Economical Reporting Criteria by 37 US Issuers; Proposed Guideline. Securities and Exchange Commission payment. SEC (2010). Commission Assertion in Support of Convergence and Global Accounting Criteria. Securities and Exchange Commission payment. Shleifer, A. (2005). 'Understanding regulation '. European Financial Management, eleven: 439-451. Squam Lake Working Group upon Financial Regulation. (2009). A brand new Information System for Economical Markets. Operating paper. Authorities on Overseas Relations, Centre for Geoeconomic Studies, Feb . 2009. Stigler, G. (1971). 'The theory of economical regulation '. Bell Diary of Economics and Supervision Science, a couple of: 3-21. Sunder, S. (2002). 'Regulatory competition among account-
US Treasury (2009). 'A new base: rebuilding economic supervision and regulation '. Financial Regulatory Reform. Vyas, D. (2009). 'Financial credit reporting transparency people financial institutions during the current financial crisis '. Operating paper. School of Barcelone. Verrecchia, 3rd there’s r. (1983). 'Discretionary disclosure '. Journal of Accounting and Economics. 5: 179-194. W, R. and Zimmerman, M. (1986). Great Accounting Theory. Englewood Coves, NJ: Prentice Hall. Zeff, S. (2005a). 'The advancement of US GAAP: the political forces lurking behind professional standards part one particular '. CPA (CERTIFIED PUBLIC ACCOUNTANT) Journal, seventy five (January): 18-27. Zeff, H. (2005b). 'The evolution individuals GAAP: the political makes behind specialist standards part 2 '. CPA Diary, 75 (February): 19-29.
Copyright laws of Accounting & Organization Research is the house of Croner. CCH Group Limited and its particular content is probably not copied or emailed to multiple sites or submitted to a listserv without the copyright laws holder is actually express created permission. However , users might print, down load, or email articles for seperate use.